In praise of pears

A few weeks ago, a box of pears arrived on my doorstep. My friends, Scott and Maggie McManus, own a pear and apple orchard near Cashmere, Washington, and they’d sent the box as a birthday present.

And what a delight it was to have all those delicious little Seckel pears.

Seckels are the smallest commercially grown pears and you don’t often see them in the store. It’s said that a Pennsylvania trapper discovered this type of pear on a seedling tree on a  piece of woodland he bought in 1765. He later sold the land to a farmer named Seckel who introduced the pears to the public.

Those pears were inspiring. I tried drawing them, even though my drawing didn’t quite capture the lovely shades of color and light.

Since I had so many pears, at first I thought I would use some of them in cooking. But aside from a few that billowed into over-ripeness, I never did.  I just ate them (and shared some of them too) as they ripened, sweet, spicy and firm.  I ate sliced pears on my morning’s steel-cut oats, added them to a salad with toasted walnuts, served them with cheese and crackers.

But mostly, I just plucked them out of the bowl and ate them, one or two at a time for a snack or dessert.

Seckel pears are one of more than 5,000 varieties of pears grown in the world.

The secret is in the ripening.  You really have pay attention to pears to know just when they’re ripe. I once wrote an essay about this called Life lessons plucked from pears, which was published in The Christian Science Monitor.  Here’s an excerpt from that:

A perfectly ripened pear is a delight to the palate, with a delicate, aromatic flavor and a tender, smooth texture. The pear suggests a European sensibility, a luxuriant, refined appreciation for the finer things in life.

But the pear resists ease of enjoyment. As with so many luxuries, the perfectly ripened pear seems always just out of reach, maddeningly elusive.

Its ripening habits are confounding: Not only must pears be picked before they are ripe, but the picked fruit ripens from the inside to the outside. When a pear is soft to the touch, it is usually rotten at its core. And, except for Bartletts, pears don’t change color to indicate ripeness. A grass-green pear can be ripe – or not.

All these ripening quirks have caused many people I know to abandon pears, or nearly so. They’ve cut into hard pears with undeveloped flavor or grainy texture, and they’ve thrown away pears that had gone rotten, their flesh brown and mushy beneath a deceptively unchanging skin.

A friend told me that, in 30 years of eating Anjou pears, he’d eaten only three ripe ones. And a pear grower confided that “a ripe Anjou is a freak of nature.”

Press a pear gently near the base of the stem; if it yields slightly, it's ripe.

British food writer Jane Grigson contends that “most people have never eaten a decent pear in their lives.”  That elusive moment of ripeness is fleeting –hence, an old saying that one must stay awake all night to eat a pear at that perfect moment.

But–ah! — when you do catch that ripe moment, it’s a real delight. You can see why Homer called pears “the gift of the gods” and Louix XIV (who loved all sorts of fruits) named the pear as one of his favorites. And that was  before pears really became the wonderful fruit we know today.

The French learned how to grow pears and peaches on espaliered trees, and in the 18th century, starting with Nicolas Hardenpont in 1730, Belgians bred buttery soft juicy varieties that made pears even more delectable. Belgians developed such an obsession about pears and pear-breeding that it’s been compared to Holland’s tulip craze.

In the 19th century, this great enthusiasm for pears also took hold of New England, a phenomenon so extraordinary it has been called “pear mania.”

Just imagine what a treat it was to eat a sweet juicy pear in mid-winter, in the days before one could buy transported or imported fruit in the grocery store.

The holiday season, with all its rich sweets, is a great time to pause and appreciate the fruit’s combined gift of nature and science (fruit breeding)–and to practice the patience and attention needed to produce a perfectly ripe pear.

If by chance your pears do over-ripen, cut out any brown portions and put them in your compost; then cook the rest, with a bit of water, down to a tasty puree, with or without spices. Recently, I waited too long to eat some Comice pears, but the pear mash I made from them was delicious. I’ve used such a mash or puree just like applesauce, or added it for a subtly sweet flavor to a  butternut-squash soup. You could even keep cooking it until you have pear butter to spread on your toast.

If, on the other hand, you have been paying attention to your pears and have a number of them that ripen at once, you could use them to make a nice dessert. I really like Boscs for baking, but I recently had a fabulous Bartlett pear tart with a rich almond crust (Steve, unfortunately, is allergic to almonds, so I won’t be making this.)

Marcella Hazan has an uncharacteristically simple recipe for a “Farm Wife’s Fresh Pear Tart.” (She says the cake has been described as being “so simple that only an active campaign of sabotage could ruin it.”). It’s a tender fruity cake studded with cloves and it’s quite tasty. Russ Parsons suggests making a pear clafouti with Bartletts, and that sounds good too.

My favorite pear dessert is a pear version of Tarte Tatin: you caramelize the pears in a skillet, lay a puff pastry atop, and pop the skillet in the oven.  After baking you turn the skillet upside down so the pastry is on the bottom and the pears are on top. It’s quite delicious and lovely.

Firm Bosc pears are best for this as they retain their shape.

Caramelized Pear Tart

  • 4 medium-large Bosc pears (about 2 pounds), firm-ripe
  • ¼ cup unsalted butter
  • ½ cup sugar
  • ¼ teaspoon cinnamon
  • ¼ teaspoon ginger
  • 1 sheet of frozen puff pastry, thawed
  1. Peel, halve, and core pears.
  2. Heat the butter in a 10-inch cast-iron or other ovenproof skillet over moderate heat, until foam subsides.   Stir in sugar (the mixture will be thick) and arrange pears, cut sides up, in the skillet (if you prefer, you can cut pears into quarters or eighths, and arrange in concentric circles).  Sprinkle the pears with cinnamon and ginger. (You could add a little lemon zest too.)
  3. Cook without stirring until the sugar mixture is a deep golden caramel.  This will take from 15-25 minutes. Watch carefully, as the mixture can burn if left on the heat too long.   Cool pears completely in skillet.
  4. Preheat oven to 425 degrees.
  5. On a lightly floured surface, roll out the puff pastry sheet and trim to form an 11-inch circle.  Arrange over the pears, tucking the edges under the pears.  Bake in the center of the oven until the pastry is golden brown, about 25 to 30 minutes.

This time I used phyllo dough instead of puff pastry on top

6.  While the tart is baking, take out a serving plate slightly larger than the skillet.  As soon as the tart has finished baking, and wearing oven mitts, press the plate over the skillet, and immediately invert the plate and skillet, keeping them firmly pressed together.  When you lift the skillet, you’ll see a beautiful, glossy tart, with the crust now on the bottom.

Serve the tart slightly warm or at room temperature.

Granted, it’s a little scary the first time or two that you have to flip the pan over onto the plate or platter (and a cast iron skillet is heavy, though it works great). Don’t worry that the pears will stick to the skillet–they will release from the pan unless you’ve let it cool too long. If any little bit sticks, you can just scrape it out.

If the whole idea makes you  nervous, you might want to start with making a half version of the recipe, using a small skillet.

Gingerbread with caramelized pears

Using the same method (pouring the cake batter over the pears), I’ve also made gingerbread with caramelized pears.

This pear season, though, I haven’t made any of these pear desserts.

Instead, I’ve just been contemplating pears, waiting for them to ripen to perfection, and enjoying the look and the taste of them.

Aren’t they beautiful?



Filed under breakfast, dessert, fall, fruit, musings, Praise for other cooks, salad, Uncategorized, winter

4 responses to “In praise of pears

  1. lily

    looks awesome toby! hello from Naivasha!

  2. Cathy mihalik

    I’m lucky to have had a perfect pear but there doesn’t seem to be an easy way to decide when one is ripe. How did you know when the Seckels were ripe???
    Thanks for the post. I inspired to start baking.

  3. martha herzog

    thanks toby for a fabulous posting about “the amazing pear”
    the history is so interesting…and i love the quote from jane grigson…
    i think that i may have hit on the moment last night at 10:30p…
    a wonderful comice!
    can’t wait to try some of these recipes..i’ve always loved pear and ginger….
    have a great recipe that i forgot about…pear/ginger tiny cakes.mmmmmm!
    ps you know i looove your beautiful pear drawings…..thanks again…

  4. Rick Steigmeyer

    Wonderful pear post, Toby. I’ll have to make a tart with my remaining pears from Scott.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s